Lower the Age?

Kyle Reed // @kylereed

I have a friend who spent time in Germany as a missionary. He talked about how the teenagers viewed drinking as a social gathering, not as a party activity. He talked about how it was completely different, there was respect and honor inside of drinking a beer, and it was done with all ages, not just with a bunch of high schoolers gathered in a basement.

What if we lowered the drinking age to 18? Would it change anything? Would it make a difference for all the binge drinkers and drunk drivers? I read a very interesting article on CNN.com the other day (Check the article here). The basic assumption of the article is that the age limit and restriction of drinking alcohol for minors is not working. The stats continue to rise, specifically amongst women.

I think the interesting thing about all of is that the age requirement really only affects people who want to drink in public. It is like a high schooler said to me, “if you want to drink you can find somewhere to drink.” I am 23, I never drank any alcohol until I was 21. Why? Partially because I knew that it was illegal, but mainly because my group of friends had an understanding about alcohol and getting drunk. We were not into that stuff. We would rather do other things and entertain ourselves that way. I would not call it peer pressure, but I would say that we influenced each other in ways to call each other beyond that.

I have heard the argument that if you tell someone to not eat out of the cookie jar they are bound to do to eat out of the cookie jar. I find it interesting how rules motivate us to break them. It would be interesting to see what happened if the drinking age was lowered. But I do not think it will solve the overall problem. Students are not being called up, they are not being challenged and they are not being influenced. We have to many followers following the wrong thins. Go back to my situation in high school. We were not perfect students, we made mistakes and got in trouble. Yet we called each other up, we called each other to growth. Challenging each other in knowledge and Christianity, constantly working together to make it through high school. There was a great understanding that if one of us failed or messed up they were not just letting themselves down, they were letting the group down. We all held each other accountable and cared for each other.

Lowering the age could make a difference, but it will not make a difference in America. We are saturated with the idea that we are untouchable, we can do whatever we want and there will be no consequences. Until we realize who we are, realizing that we are in this together and are holding each other accountable to a higher standard an age restriction will mean nothing to us.

What are your thoughts on this subject?
What is your reaction to the article.

Would love for your comments and thoughts on this touchy subject.



3 Week Course To Launching Your Blog

For a limited time this 3 week course is available to the first 25 people who sign-up. This 6 week course will guide you through how to set up a blog, write 25 blog post, and customize your look. This is a limited time offer made available only to the first 25 people

Kyle Reed

Posts Twitter

I create websites, conversations, and ideas. Advocate for the 20 somethings. Looking to connect everyone to a mentor. Married to my best friend, Ginny. I like my coffee black and my dog Jack. I currently live in Nashville and work at Sony Music/Provident in Nashville
  • calamusink

    You said, "There was a great understanding that if one of us failed or messed up they were not just letting themselves down, they were letting the group down. We all held each other accountable and cared for each other."

    What a great explanation of accountability and ownership of community.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/klreed189 klreed189

      appreciate it, thanks.
      What do you think about the article.

  • O23

    I've never been to Germany, but I would guess that drinking alcohol doesn't fit into a system of standards (referring to your "higher standards"), and in my mind this is why it is treated differently. Why does not drinking alcohol mean you have higher standards?

    I think you're right about the age thing though. Changing the age won't make a difference because in America beer and alcohol are marketed as a party, not as a low-key social gathering. EVERYTHING IS MARKETING.

    …Which is why if we legalized marijuana the government could have a shot at making it a change for the good if they could come up with a great marketing plan instead of letting some company who's trying to turn a profit show why 'more is better.' However, our government has quite a history of being some of the worst marketers out there. Look at the Iraq/Afghanistan war…

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/klreed189 klreed189

      I didn't mean it that way. All I was saying was that we had higher standards of what we were going to do with out time, for example not break the law or get drunk to have fun. I am not playing the holy roller card here, all I am saying was that we viewed drinking as a major temptation, but felt that God was calling us above that and so we held each other accountable to that. As well, we had a major temptation with smoking, girls, lust, cheating on homework, etc….we were not perfect, but we worked together in an effort to rise above these temptations.

      I do think you are right, that drinking is marketed as being cool which in turn makes you cool if you do it. The government has done a terrible job of marketing, and your example of the war is good.

  • O23

    i know kyle, just giving you a hard time. you're so gay. did you get a new job yet?

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/klreed189 klreed189

      nope still waiting